When "how are you" becomes a hard question

Stage 1 · The first 90 days · Article 04 · Wave 1

---

Someone asks how you're doing and you don't know what to say. The honest answer is too long. The polite answer feels like a lie. The short version doesn't fit. You stand there working out which version to deliver, while the other person waits.

This article covers why this question is harder than it used to be, three answers calibrated to different audiences, what to do when the honest answer wants to come out, and when to start asking back.

Why the question is harder now

Before the separation, how are you had a default answer (fine, you?) and the exchange moved on. The question was a social ritual, not an actual inquiry.

After the separation, three things change.

1. The default answer feels false. You're not fine. Saying fine feels like lying. Saying anything else feels like oversharing. You're caught between two failures.

2. The question lands harder. The body, which is already managing more than it usually does, gets one more thing to manage. A neutral social interaction now requires conscious processing.

3. You don't know which version of yourself is in the room. Some days you're holding it together. Some days you're not. The same question hits differently on different days. You can't pre-decide an answer because the answer depends on the day.

The cumulative effect is that ordinary social interactions become draining in ways they didn't used to be. Most parents in the first 90 days notice they're avoiding casual social contact, often without knowing why. This is why.

Three answers, calibrated to audience

Pre-decide your answer for three categories. When the question comes, you know which to use.

For acquaintances and colleagues

Doing alright, thanks. How are you?

The pivot back to them is the most important part. Acquaintances rarely want a real answer; they want the ritual completed. The pivot returns the ball and ends the exchange in three seconds. This isn't lying. It's recognising that the question was social, not investigative, and answering at the level it was asked.

If the acquaintance does want a real answer (rare), they'll ask a follow-up. Really, how are you, with everything? Then you can shift register. Until they do, stay at the level they asked.

For people who know about the separation but aren't close

Some days are easier than others. Mostly okay.

This is the honest middle-distance answer. It signals that you're not pretending to be fine, but you're not opening the conversation for processing. Most people receiving this will respond with a small warm thing (hang in there, thinking of you) and the conversation moves on.

The phrase mostly okay does specific work. It accepts that things are hard without dramatising. It doesn't require the listener to do anything. It doesn't make them responsible for your wellbeing.

For close friends and family

Today is a [hard / okay / surprisingly fine] day. [One specific thing about today.]

For people who actually want to know, give them a specific, current data point. Not the whole picture. Just where today sits.

Examples:

• Today is hard. The Co-Parent and I had a difficult call last night and I haven't slept.
• Today is okay. I had a good walk this morning. Tomorrow might be different.
• Today is surprisingly fine. I'm not sure why. I'm not interrogating it.

The specificity gives the listener something to respond to. The honest current state gives them accurate information. The implicit acknowledgement that tomorrow might be different removes the pressure for the listener to fix today.

What to do when the honest answer wants to come out

Sometimes, with a particular person, in a particular moment, the honest answer is going to come out whether you planned it or not. Your eyes start to fill. The voice catches. The polite version isn't available.

A few things to know:

1. This is okay. You're not weak. You're not oversharing. You're a separated parent in the first 90 days, and sometimes the body decides to be honest before the mind has chosen.

2. Give yourself one sentence. Even when the honest answer is wanting out, you don't have to deliver the whole thing. I'm having a hard week, sorry. That's enough. The listener will adjust.

3. Have a recovery line ready. After the honest sentence, you can pivot back: I'm okay though, thank you for asking. This isn't dishonesty. It's signalling that you don't need them to do anything about it.

4. Pick where this happens. The honest answer in the school car park to another parent you barely know is different from the honest answer to your sister on the phone. Try to notice the setting. If you can hold it for one more minute and find a better place, do that. If you can't, you can't. Both are fine.

The reverse question, when to start asking back

About four to six weeks into the separation, most parents notice they've stopped asking other people how they are. The bandwidth is gone. Every interaction is taking energy you don't have to spare for additional inquiry.

This is fine, temporarily. But after about three months, the absence of reciprocal asking starts to wear on friendships. Friends notice when you've stopped asking. Most won't say anything. Some will pull back.

Around week 12, try this: in three conversations this week, ask one real question of the other person. How's the new job? How was the holiday? How's your mother doing? You don't need to have a long conversation. You just need to demonstrate that they're a person to you, not just a support.

This is one of the first signals to the people who held you up in the early weeks that you're starting to come back. They will notice. Most won't comment on it. Some will quietly resume sharing things with you that they stopped sharing in week three because they didn't want to add to your load.

When the question lands particularly hard

A small subset of how are you moments produce a disproportionate response. The cashier asks, and you cry in the supermarket. A colleague asks, and you have to leave the room. A stranger on a flight asks, and you find yourself telling them more than you've told your siblings.

This isn't a problem to solve. It's a signal that the body had something it needed to discharge and the question was the trigger. Strangers and casual acquaintances are sometimes safer recipients precisely because there's no relationship to manage afterwards.

If this is happening often, the underlying signal is that you need more deliberate processing channels, a therapist, a journal, a regular walk where you process out loud to yourself, a friend with a scheduled phone slot. The body is showing up to discharge in unscheduled places because it doesn't have scheduled ones.

Quick reference

Pre-decide your answer for three audiences:

1. Acquaintances/colleagues: Doing alright, thanks. You?
2. People who know but aren't close: Some days are easier than others. Mostly okay.
3. Close people: Today is [hard / okay / fine]. [One specific data point.]

If the honest answer wants to come out:

• One sentence is enough.
• Have a recovery line ready.
• Notice the setting; choose if you can.

Around week 12:

• Start asking one real question back, in three conversations this week.
• The people who supported you are watching for this signal.

The honest answer doesn't have to be the whole answer. One sentence is enough.